We discuss two formulations of the Pattern Minimization Problem: (1) introduced by Vanderbeck, and (2) obtained adding setup variables to the cutting stock formulation by Gilmore-Gomory. Let $z_i^{LP}(u)$ be the bound given by the linear relaxation of ($i$) under a given vector $u = (u_k)$ of parameters. We show that $z_2^{LP}(u}) \ge z_1^{LP}(u)$ and provide a class of instances for which the inequality holds strict. We observe that the linear relaxation of both formulations can be solved by the same column generation procedure, and discuss the critical role of parameters $u$. The paper is completed by a numerical test comparing the lower bounds obtained through (1) and (2) for different values of $u$.

## Citation

NETWORKS, 57, 3 (2011) p. 247-253, DOI 10.1002/net