For decades, researchers have complained that contiguity constraints make problems like districting much harder than other combinatorial optimization problems. This has prompted the use of integer programming models with inexact contiguity constraints that may be fast in practice but are invalid in the sense that they cut off or “overlook” some contiguous solutions. Examples include … Read more
We consider a fundamental question in political districting: How many counties can be kept whole (i.e., not split across multiple districts), while satisfying basic criteria like contiguity and population balance? To answer this question, we propose integer programming techniques based on combinatorial Benders decomposition. The main problem decides which counties to keep whole, and the … Read more
Consider the task of dividing a state into k contiguous political districts whose populations must not differ by more than one person, following current practice for congressional districting in the USA. A widely held belief among districting experts is that this task requires at least k-1 county splits. This statement has appeared in expert testimony, … Read more